The Phoenix Network:
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures

The Neda video and the definition of journalism

Writing at Gawker, John Cook argues that the decision to give a George Polk award to the unidentified (wo)man who caught Neda Agha-Soltan's death on video raises some big questions about what it means to practice "journalism":

[W]hen you start handing out awards that were created to "honor special achievement in journalism" with an emphasis on "investigative and enterprise work that is original, requires digging and resourcefulness and brings results" to works that consist of finding yourself next to a horrible thing and pulling your camera phone out of your pocket—well, what's the point of calling anything journalism anymore?

There isn't one! But that's claim that you expect to hear from folks who celebrate the deprofessionalization of the news media and increased unmediated access to mass communications technology. When it comes from the proprietors of a 61-year-old award that's long served as part of an institutional infrastructure that vests control of the news environment to a cloistered caste of pedigreed journalists, it's kind of confusing. Self-undermining, even....

The Neda video is valuable because it's the only record of the murder and the most graphic record of the regime's violence. But that value derives not from the videographer's efforts, or even bravery. It derives from the fact that there's no other video of it. If the video had come from, say, a nearby surveillance camera rather than a cell phone, it would be just as valuable. But who would get the Polk?

This is interesting stuff--but I've got a couple problems with Cook's analysis. First, the exclusivity he's talking about has always been a standard of journalistic worth: many iconic photos got to be that way because (to paraphrase Cook) there was no other photo of the event pictured.

Also: it's actually not surprising that the Polk Awards, with this particular citation, are pushing the limits of what "journalism" means. Remember: they did exactly the same thing two years ago, when Joshua Marshall won a Polk for Talking Points Memo's coverage of the US Attorney firing scandal, thereby becoming a case study in new-media success. 

These two Polk awards--plus other examples of old-media broadmindedness, e.g., the Pulitzer committee's decision to consider online-only publications--may be a bit self-undermining, as Cook argues. Anything that further destabilizes the professional media's monopoly on the news is. But if the alternative is sticking with a stodgy, antiquated version of what "journalism" means, that's a risk worth taking.

| More


  • RRRR said:

    Speaking of "journalism" ...... Adam Reilly

    A few years ago I remember you wrote an article called "Same as the old Blog" where you made the prediction that would

    "peter out in a couple of months"

    You can find the article here =>

    Well it's been 3 years and the blog has grown.  

    Any thoughts?  

    February 17, 2010 8:03 AM
  • C. said:

    Your argument does not make sense to me at all. Josh Marshall works online, and runs his own company --- but he is clearly a professional journalist, who earns a paycheck writing, editing, interviewing, and offerring opinons on the news. The Neda videographer is no more a professional journalist than Zapruder was. Te recognize a member of the profession practicing in a new medium is quite a different thing than giving an award to an amatuer who happenned to bear witness to a historic event. These lines are blurring, sure. There are plenty of part time unpaid bloggers out there doing reporting (though Marshall ain't one of them). But Neda's videographer clearly falls on one side of that line. If anyone with a cameraphone is a journalist, then there are no such things as journalists.

    February 17, 2010 9:50 AM
  • Adam Reilly said:

    Great timing, RRRR!

    C, I didn't argue that Marshall = the Neda videographer--only that the Polk Awards seem to be making a point of stretching the definitional boundaries of legit journalism.

    February 17, 2010 3:40 PM

Leave a Comment

Login | Not a member yet? Click here to Join
 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
All Blogs
Related Articles

Boston Phoenix
Azerbaijani meat with chestnuts and sour plums
Published 2/11/2011 by LINDSAY STERLING
A Valentine's Day invitation

Boston Phoenix
What's gotten into Egypt?
Published 2/4/2011 by EDITORIAL
Plus, Republicans for same-sex marriage, and trying to kill health-care reform

more by Adam Reilly
Bully for BU! | March 12, 2010
Stop the Quinn-sanity! | March 05, 2010
WBUR's new, improved "Radio Boston" | March 01, 2010
Pew takes stock of the brave new media world | February 28, 2010
My impending departure | February 26, 2010

 See all articles by: Adam Reilly

Follow the Phoenix
  • newsletter
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • youtube
  • rss
Latest Comments
Tea Party Enabling Billionaire David H. Koch Moonlights as WGBH Board Member - The serious top-hole of Advanced York City is the bravery center of the nation. It is a director in manufacturing...

By colabiedrona on 03-04-2011 in Phlog

Rest In Peace Roc Dukati - R.I.P Roc Dukati my condolences go out to the whole entire Life4Life team & family!

By Mo-Better on 03-04-2011 in On The Download

Rest In Peace Roc Dukati - R.I.P Roc Dukati my condolences go out to the whole entire Life4Life team & family!

By Mo-Better on 03-04-2011 in On The Download

iTunes releases "The Hunger," new Shirley Manson track off Prometheus Bound - How can you write a story about Shirley Manson and not include a single photo of her? Disturbing!

By Ryan on 03-03-2011 in On The Download

Tea Party Enabling Billionaire David H. Koch Moonlights as WGBH Board Member - This is Glenn Beck-level dot connecting. Puh-leeze. The Kochs may be evil in many aspects of their political...

By mfo817 on 03-02-2011 in Phlog

Latest Comments from Dont Quote Me
Most Viewed
Cave In to perform Thursday in Allston
Black Milk Wednesday Night @ Wonder Bar in Allston!!!
[Q&A] Gang Of Four's Jon King on terrorists, funk music and asking the hard questions
WFNX Boston Accents playlist 02.06.11
Boston Phoenix vs Ryan's Smashing Life: 02.17.11 @ Great Scott
[phlipcam video] Comanche @ Wadzilla Mansion
[video] Earthquake Party! live from the archive
Most Viewed from Dont Quote Me
Search Blogs
Dont Quote Me Archives
Saturday, March 05, 2011  |  Sign In  |  Register
Phoenix Media/Communications Group
Copyright © 2011 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group